A study of the Course of Transformation in Contemporary Persian Love poetry: From the Early Shifts in the Qajar Era to Its Development in the Ahmad-e Shamlu's Works

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Department of Persian Language and Literature, Shiraz University, Shiraz , Iran

Abstract
Love has long held a unique and indispensable place in the cultural and intellectual life of Iranians, standing as one of the most fundamental and multifaceted concepts in Persian literary history. Yet the representation of love in Persian literary tradition has never been static or timeless. On the contrary, it has continually been shaped and reshaped by the historical, social, and philosophical undercurrents of each era, giving rise to new literary configurations over time. What makes these transformations particularly significant is their gradual, process-driven nature. Adopting an analytical approach informed by the theories of Bakhtin and Saussure—and emphasizing the procedural nature of literary evolution—this study investigates the initial signs of transformation in Persian love poetry during the modern era, beginning with the Qajar period. By examining the early encounters with Western thought, it reveals how these intellectual interactions shaped contemporary love poetry and gradually culminated in the works of Ahmad Shamlu. The findings of this study indicate that Shamlu was not the initiator of this transformation but rather its continuation and culmination. Drawing on the intellectual and literary heritage of his predecessors, Shamlu crafted a form of love poetry that meaningfully departed—both in content and expression—from classical traditions as well as the works of his contemporaries. In doing so, he established a defining and influential model for contemporary Persian love poetry.

Keywords

Subjects

Persian Sources
A. Shīrāz (1330). “She’r-e Fārsī va She’r-e Now”, Kabūtar-e Ṣolḥ. No. 18: pp. 31-37.
Ādamīyat, Fereydūn (1357). Andīshe-hā-ye Mīrzā Āghā Khān Kermānī, Tehrān: Payām.
Ākhūndzādeh, Mīrzā Fatḥ-‘alī (2535). Maghālāt-e Fārsī, be kūshesh-e Ḥamīd Moḥammadzādeh. Tehrān: Negāh.
Āl-e Aḥmad, Jalāl (1379). “Moghaddame-ī ke dar khvor-e boland-e shā’er nabūd”, in Az Noghte tā Khat (Majmū’e-ye Naghd va Nazar darbāre-ye Noṣrat Raḥmānī), be kūshesh-e Maḥmūd Nīkūyeh, Tehrān: Ṭā’atī.
Aman-khānī, ‘Īsā (1401). Darbāre-ye Tajaddod-e Adabī, Eṣfahān: Khāmūsh.
Amīnī, Maftūn (1378). “Gozāreshī az Bayān-e ‘Eshgh dar Dowre-hā va Gūne-hā-ye She’r-e Fārsī”, Majalle-ye Farhang va Towse’e, No. 42-43, Tehrān, 150-159.
Āryānpūr, Yaḥyā (1351). Az Ṣabā tā Nīmā, Vol. 1, Tehrān: Sherkat-e Sahāmī bā hamkārī-ye Mo’assese-ye Enteshārāt-e Frānklīn.
Bal’amī, Abū-‘alī Moḥammad ebn-e Moḥammad (1353). Takmele va Tarjome-ye Tārīkh-e Ṭabarī, taṣḥīḥ-e Moḥammad-Taghī Bahār, be kūshesh-e Moḥammad Parvīn Gonābādī, Vol. 2, Tehrān: Enteshārāt-e Zavvār.
Behfar, Mehrī (1381). “Man o To Yekī Dīdegānīm”, Aḥmad Shāmlū; Shā’er-e Shabāne-hā va ‘Āsheghāne-hā, be kūshesh-e Behrūz Ṣāḥeb-ekhtīārī va Ḥamīd-Rezā Bāgherzādeh, Tehrān: Hīrmand, 282-303.
Dehghānī, Moḥammad (1397). Vasvase-ye ‘Āsheghī, Barrasī-ye Taḥavvol-e Mafhūm-e ‘Eshgh dar Farhang va Adabīyāt-e Fārsī, Tehrān: Nashr-e Roshd-e Javāne.
Eṣfahāniān, Dāvūd (1379). “Ta’sīr-e Īlghār-e Moghol dar Masīr-e Tārīkh-e Īrān”, Majmū’e-maghālāt-e Avvalīn Semīnār-e Tārīkhī-ye Hojūm-e Moghol be Īrān va Payāmad-hā-ye ān, ed. Vahhāb Valī, Vol. 1, Tehrān: Dāneshgāh-e Shahīd Beheshtī, 71-82.
Falakī, Maḥmūd (1380). Negāhī be She’r-e Shāmlū, Tehrān: Morvārīd.
Farrokhzād, Forūgh (1348). Dīvār, Tehrān: Amīrkabīr.
_________________ (1375). Jāvedāne Zīstan, dar Owj Māndan, be kūshesh-e Behrūz Jalālī, Tehrān: Morvārīd.
Fotūḥī Rūd-ma’janī, Maḥmūd (1395). Ṣad Sāl ‘Eshgh-e Majāzī; Maktab-e Vāsūkht dar She’r-e Fārsī-ye Gharn-e Dahom, Tehrān: Sokhan.
Ḥāfeẓ, Shams-od-Dīn Moḥammad (1377). Dīvān-e Ḥāfeẓ, be kūshesh-e Khalīl Khaṭīb Rahbar, Tehrān: Ṣafī ‘Alī-Shāh.
Ḥarīrī, Nāṣer (1385). Darbāre-ye Honar va Adabīyāt, Goft-o-gū-ye Nāṣer Ḥarīrī bā Shāmlū, Tehrān: Negāh.
Īlchī, Mīrzā Abolḥasan Khān (1364). Ḥeyrat-nāme; Safarnāme-ye Mīrzā Abolḥasan Khān Īlchī be London, be kūshesh-e Ḥasan Morsalvand, Tehrān: Mo’assese-ye Khadamāt-e Farhangī-ye Rasā.
Kazāzī, Jalāl-od-Dīn (1390). Nāme-ye Bāstān, Vol. 9, Tehrān: Enteshārāt-e Samt.
Kermānī, Mīrzā Āghā Khān (1384). Ṣad Khaṭābe-ye Mīrzā Āghā Khān Kermānī, ed. Moḥammad-Ja’far Maḥjūb, Los Angeles: Sherkat-e Ketāb.
Kūshesh, Raḥīm va Nūrī, Zahrā (1395). “Taḥlīl-e Ab’ād-e Tārīkh-e Mazmūn-e ‘Eshgh dar Ash’ār-e Aḥmad Shāmlū”, Dorr-e Darī (Adabīyāt-e Ghanāyī, ‘Erfānī), Year 6, No. 19, 43-52.
Lāhūtī, Abolghāsem (1358). Dīvān-e Lāhūtī, be kūshesh-e Aḥmad Bashīrī, Tehrān: Amīrkabīr.
Langrūdī, Shams (1377). Tārīkh-e Taḥlīlī-ye She’r-e Now, Vol. 1, 2nd ed., Tehrān: Markaz.
Marāghe-ī, Zeyn-ol-‘Ābedīn (1403). Sīyāḥat-nāme-ye Ebrāhīm Beyk, be kūshesh-e M.A. Sepānlū, Tehrān: Āgah.
Mīr-‘ābedīnī, Ḥasan (1380). Ṣad Sāl Dāstān-nevīsī-ye Īrān, Vol. 1 & 2, Tehrān: Cheshme.
Mīrzā Abūṭāleb Khān (1352). Masīr-e Ṭālebī yā Safarnāme-ye Mīrzā Abūṭāleb Khān, be kūshesh-e Ḥoseyn Khadīv-Jam, Tehrān: Asāṭīr.
Madī, Arzhang (1371). ‘Eshgh dar Adab-e Fārsī: Az Āghāz tā Gharn-e Sheshom, Tehrān: Mo’assese-ye Moṭāle’āt va Taḥghīghāt-e Farhangī.
Moḥsenī, Mortezā et al. (1395). “Sīmā-ye Ma’shūgh va Kījā dar Robā’īyāt va Rūjā-ye Nīmā”, Majmū’e-maghālāt-e Hamāyesh-e ‘Elmī-Pazhūheshī-ye Nīmā, Zabān va She’r-e Tabarī, Sārī: Hāozhīn.
Mokhtārī, Moḥammad (1378). Haftād Sāl She’r-e ‘Āsheghāne, Taḥlīlī az Zehnīyat-e Ghanāyī-ye Mo’āṣer, Tehrān: Tīrāzheh.
Morādī, Narges; Taslīmī, ‘Alī; Khazāne-dārlū, Moḥammad-‘alī (1397). “Ma’shūgh-e Īde-āl, Ma’shūgh-Mādar; Barrasī-ye Lakānī-ye ‘Eshgh dar She’r-e Bar Sarmā-ye Darūn-e Aḥmad Shāmlū”, Adabīyāt-e Pārsī-ye Mo’āṣer, Year 8, No. 1, 207-232.
Nāderpūr, Nāder (1382). Majmū’e Ash’ār, Tehrān: Negāh.
Nāyeb-ol-Iyāle, Rezā Gholī Mīrzā (1361). Safarnāme-ye Rezā Gholī Mīrzā Nāyeb-ol-Iyāle, be kūshesh-e Aṣghar Farmān-farmāyī Ghājār, Tehrān: Asāṭīr.
Neẓāmī, Elyās ebn-e Yūsef (1378). Khosrow va Shīrīn, bā taṣḥīḥ va ḥavāshī-ye Ḥasan Vaḥīd Dastgerdī, be kūshesh-e Sa’īd Ḥamīdīān, Tehrān: Ghaṭre.
Nīmā Yūshīj (1368). Darbāre-ye She’r va Shā’erī, tadvīn-e Sīrūs Ṭāhbāz, Tehrān: Daftar-hā-ye Zamāne.
___________ (1373). Majmū’e-ye Kāmel-e Ash’ār-e Nīmā, tadvīn-e Sīrūs Ṭāhbāz, Tehrān: Negāh.
___________ (1376). Majmū’e-ye Kāmel-e Nāme-hā-ye Nīmā Yūshīj, tadvīn-e Sīrūs Ṭāhbāz, Tehrān: Nashr-e ‘Elm.
Pūrjavādī, Naṣrollāh (1398). Bāde-ye ‘Eshgh; Pazhūheshī dar Ma’nā-ye Bāde dar She’r-e Fārsī, Tehrān: Kārnāme.
Pūr-nāmdārīān, Taghī (1381). Safar dar Meh: Ta’ammolī dar She’r-e Shāmlū, Tehrān: Negāh.
Rafī’ī Moghaddam Kāsānī, Homā et al. (1401). “Sīyāsat-e ‘Eshgh dar ‘Āsheghāne-hā-ye Aḥmad Shāmlū”, Naghd-e Adabī, Year 15, No. 59, 153-199.
Rīpkā, Yān et al. (1370). Tārīkh-e Adabīyāt-e Īrān, trans. Keykhosrow Keshavārzī, Tehrān: Jāvīdān Kherad.
Rūdakī, Ja’far ebn-e Moḥammad (1391). Dīvān-e Rūdakī, towzīḥ va naghd va taḥlīl-e Kāmel Aḥmad-nezhād, Tehrān: Ketāb-e Āmeh.
Sa’ālabī Nīshābūrī, Abū-manṣūr (1368). Tārīkh-e Sa’ālabī (Mashhūr be Akhbār-e Molūk al-Fors va Sīyar-e-hom), Part 1, trans. Moḥammad Fazā’elī, Tehrān: Nashr-e Noghre.
Sa’dī, Moṣleḥ ebn-e ‘Abdollāh (1385). Kollīyāt-e Sa’dī, taṣḥīḥ-e Moḥammad-‘alī Forūghī, Tehrān: Hermes.
Ṣafā, Ẕabīḥollāh (1391). Tārīkh-e Adabīyāt-e Īrān, Kholāṣe-ye Vol. 3, summ. Seyyed Moḥammad Torābī, Tehrān: Ferdows.
Salājegheh, Parvīn (1395). Amīrzāde-ye Kāshī-hā: Aḥmad Shāmlū, Tehrān: Morvārīd.
Shafī’ī Kadkanī, Moḥammad-Rezā (1387). Advār-e She’r-e Fārsī; az Mashrūṭīyat tā Soghūṭ-e Salṭanat, Tehrān: Sokhan.
Shamīsā, Sīrūs (1386). Seyr-e Ghazal dar She’r-e Fārsī, 2nd ed., Tehrān: ‘Elm.
_____________ (1388). Sabk-shenāsī-ye She’r, 2nd ed., Tehrān: Mītrā.
_____________ (1326). Āhang-hā-ye Farāmūsh-shode, Tehrān: Morvārīd.
_____________ (1381). Majmū’e Āsār-e Aḥmad Shāmlū, Vol. 1: She’r-hā, Tehrān: Negāh.
Singer, Irving (1397). Falsafe-ye ‘Eshgh, trans. Meysam Moḥammad-Amīnī, Tehrān: Nashr-e Now.
Vāde, Zhān-Klūd [Vadé, Jean-Claude] (1377). Ḥadīs-e ‘Eshgh dar Shargh, trans. Javād Ḥadīdī, Tehrān: Markaz-e Nashr-e Dāneshgāhī.
Yārshāṭer, Eḥsān (1334). She’r-e Fārsī dar ‘Ahd-e Shāhrokh yā Āghāz-e Enḥeṭāṭ-e She’r-e Fārsī, Tehrān: Enteshārāt-e Dāneshgāh-e Tehrān.
 
English and French Sources
Amini, Mohammadreza. (2004). "Idée et expression de l'amour dans les œuvres de Sa'dī", Luqman, No. 2, Serial No. 40, pp. 49-65.
Bakhtin, M. (1986). Speech Genres and Other Late Essays. Translated by Vern W. McGee, Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. (1990). Art and Answerability, Translated by Vadim Liaponuv, Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, M. (1993). Toward a Philosophy of Act, Translated by Vadim Liaponuv, Texas: University of Texas Press.
Giddens, Anthony (1992). The Transformation of Intimacy: Sexuality, Love and Eroticism in Modern Societies, Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Meisami, Julie Scott (1987). Medieval Persian Court Poetry, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Morson, G. S., & Emerson, C. (1990). Mikhail Bakhtin: Creation of a Prosaics. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Najmabadi, Afsaneh (2005). Women with Mustaches and Men Without Beards: Gender and Sexual Anxieties of Iranian Modernity, Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Ouseley, William (1819-1823). Travels in Various Countries of the East; more particularly Persia. Vol 3, London: Rodwell and Martin.
Saussure, F. de. (2011). Course in General Linguistics (W. Baskin, Trans.). Columbia University Press. (Original work published 1916).
Singer, Irving (2009). The Nature of Love, Vol 1: Plato to Luther. Cambridge: The MIT Press.
___________ (2009). The Nature of Love, Vol 2: Courtly and Romantic, Cambridge: The MIT Press.
___________ (2009). The Nature of Love, Vol 3: The Modern World, Cambridge: The MIT Press.
__________ (2011). Philosophy of Love; A Partial Summing-Up, Cambridge: The MIT Press.
Tancoigne, M. (1820). A Narrative of a Journey into Persia and Residence at Tehran. Translated from French, London: William Wright.
Tavakoli-Targhi, Mohamad (2001). Refashioning Iran: Orientalism, Occidentalism and Historiography. Houndmills: Palgrave.
Wrangham, Richard W. (2009). Catching Fire, New York: Basic Books.
Zappen, James P. (2004). The Rebirth of Dialogue: Bakhtin, Socrates, and the Rhetorical Tradition, New York: State University of New York Press.